Éditoriaux Défense Sécurité Terrorisme Zones de conflits Logistique Livres de référence Liens
Terre Air Mer Gendarmerie Renseignement Infoguerre Cyber Recherche

<span style="font-weight: 400">Terror War Demonstrates Need to Update Doctrine<!-- /page-name --></span>

Terror War Demonstrates Need to Update Doctrine

By Donna Miles, American Forces Press Service

Washington D.C. -- (AFPS) April 20, 2004 -- Current military doctrine needs an overhaul to better address the challenges confronting U.S. forces in Afghanistan and Iraq, the commander of the 18th Airborne Corps told the American Forces Press Service last week at the corps headquarters at Fort Bragg, N.C. 

Lt. Gen. John R. Vines accepts the 18th Airborne Corps and Fort Bragg colors from Gen. Larry R. Ellis, commander of U.S. Forces Command, at his change of command ceremony at Fort Bragg, N.C., Aug. 26, 2003. Vines said current military doctrine was not written with operations such as Afghanistan in mind.

Lt. Gen. John R. Vines accepts the 18th Airborne Corps and Fort Bragg colors from Gen. Larry R. Ellis, commander of U.S. Forces Command, at his change of command ceremony at Fort Bragg, N.C., Aug. 26, 2003. Vines said current military doctrine was not written with operations such as Afghanistan in mind. Photo by K. Kassens, USA.

Photo by K. Kassens, USA

Army Lt. Gen. John R. Vines, commander of the Defense Department's largest warfighting organization, said current doctrine falls short in addressing the circumstances in which U.S. troops operate in Southwest Asia.

"We are so far beyond where the doctrine is in terms of how we operate that the doctrine can only be a broad guide," Vines said. "Doctrine was not designed with Afghanistan in mind. So consequently, what was written at (the Army's Training and Doctrine Command at) Fort Monroe or the Special Warfare Center (at Fort Bragg) or some other place didn't envision the complexity of what we are doing there."

This complex, non-linear battlefield has little resemblance to the Cold War model on which much of today's doctrine is based. Vines said it frequently provides no clear-cut distinctions between phases of warfare under way or the types of troops conducting operations. Also, U.S. military forces interact regularly with a wide range of noncombatants, including various U.S. government elements, nongovernmental organization representatives and groups representing the host country's central government.

"Our doctrine does not adequately address the control of this," said Vines, who commanded Coalition Joint Task Force 82 and Combined Joint Task Force 180 in Afghanistan from September 2002 to October 2003.

Vines said doctrine assumes what he calls "the old paradigm" that warfare is conducted one phase at a time — with stability operations that include building schools and digging wells kicking off only after combat operations have ceased. "The reality is that in a single piece of battle space, we might have three or four phases going on simultaneously," he said.

Military doctrine also fails to address adequately the heavy use of different special operations forces or the integral association between conventional and special operations forces on the ground, he said. Over the years, an "artificial barrier" developed between the two forces, Vines said, but that in reality, they work side by side, complementing each other's capabilities.

He said this mix of conventional and special operations forces as well as militia have proven to be "extraordinarily effective" in Afghanistan.

Vines said doctrine needs to address another battlefield complexity better than it does: the presence of a wide range of parties, most of them noncombatants. These include not just local civilians, but also representatives of nongovernmental organizations and interagency teams that are part of the U.S. government. In Afghanistan, Vines said, coalition forces also work with the Afghan National Army as well as militia members who received favored status by the Afghan government because they supported President Hamid Kharzai in fighting the Taliban.

"So occasionally, figuring out who you are dealing with becomes the challenge," said Vines. "You have to determine, does this militia have the support and authorization of the government? It isn't always easy to do."

Vines said he expects the way operations are being carried out in Afghanistan and Iraq to have a big influence on future operations. Ultimately, they too, could be incorporated into future doctrine. These include a wide mix of aviation units flying in the same battle space, the integration of Reserve and National Guard units into missions, and the use of special operations forces to do things he said "I'm not even sure their founders 60 years ago could have visualized."

One shortcoming Vines said needs to be addressed better is information operations — the ability of U.S. forces to use information to win the hearts and minds of the local population.

"If their only information comes from a mullah who is preaching hate against Westerners, Christians, Americans, the coalition, and that is their only source of information, then they will accept it at face value," Vines said. "So we have to put the facts out in a way that they say, 'Listen, the neighboring village was rebuilt, there has never been a road here before, and now there's a road.' Then they see the value of working together to rebuild their country."

Vines said mastering information operations will go a long way toward influencing people "to lay down their weapons and quit fighting and rebuild their country." But for now, he said, "We don't do that nearly as well as we could."

Biography:

Related Sites:


Derniers articles

Verdun 2016 : La légende de la « tranchée des baïonnettes »
Eyes in the Dark: Navy Dive Helmet Display Emerges as Game-Changer
OIR Official: Captured Info Describes ISIL Operations in Manbij
Cyber, Space, Middle East Join Nuclear Triad Topics at Deterrence Meeting
Carter Opens Second DoD Innovation Hub in Boston
Triomphe de St-Cyr : le Vietnam sur les rangs
Dwight D. Eisenhower Conducts First OIR Missions from Arabian Gulf
L’amiral Prazuck prend la manœuvre de la Marine
Airmen Practice Rescuing Downed Pilots in Pacific Thunder 16-2
On ne lutte pas contre les moustiques avec une Kalachnikov...
Enemy Mine: Underwater Drones Hunt Buried Targets, Save Lives
Daesh Publications Are Translated Into Eleven Languages
Opération Chammal : 10 000 heures de vol en opération pour les Mirage 2000 basés en Jordanie
Le Drian : Daech : une réponse à plusieurs niveaux
Carter: Defense Ministers Agree on Next Steps in Counter-ISIL Fight
Carter Convenes Counter-ISIL Coalition Meeting at Andrews
Carter Welcomes France’s Increased Counter-ISIL Support
100-Plus Aircraft Fly in for Exercise Red Flag 16-3
Growlers Soar With B-1s Around Ellsworth AFB
A-10s Deploy to Slovakia for Cross-Border Training
We Don’t Fight Against Mosquitoes With a Kalashnikov
Bug-Hunting Computers to Compete in DARPA Cyber Grand Challenge
Chiefs of US and Chinese Navies Agree on Need for Cooperation
DoD Cyber Strategy Defines How Officials Discern Cyber Incidents from Armed Attacks
Vice Adm. Tighe Takes Charge of Information Warfare, Naval Intelligence
Truman Strike Group Completes Eight-Month Deployment
KC-46 Completes Milestone by Refueling Fighter Jet, Cargo Plane
Air Dominance and the Critical Role of Fifth Generation Fighters
Une nation est une âme
The Challenges of Ungoverned Spaces
Carter Salutes Iraqi Forces, Announces 560 U.S. Troops to Deploy to Iraq
Obama: U.S. Commitment to European Security is Unwavering in Pivotal Time for NATO
International Court to Decide Sovereignty Issue in South China Sea
La SPA 75 est centenaire !
U.S. to Deploy THAAD Missile Battery to South Korea
Maintien en condition des matériels : reprendre l’initiative
La veste « léopard », premier uniforme militaire de camouflage
Océan Indien 2016 : Opérations & Coopération
Truman Transits Strait of Gibraltar
Navy Unveils National Museum of the American Sailor
New Navy, Old Tar
Marcel Dassault parrain de la nouvelle promotion d’officiers de l’École de l’Air
RIMPAC 2016 : Ravitaillement à la mer pour le Prairial avant l’arrivée à Hawaii
Bataille de la Somme, l’oubliée
U.S., Iceland Sign Security Cooperation Agreement
Cléopatra : la frégate Jean Bart entre dans l’histoire du BPC Gamal Abdel Nasser
Surveiller l’espace maritime français aussi par satellite
America's Navy-Marine Corps Team Fuse for RIMPAC 2016
Stratégie France : Plaidoyer pour une véritable coopération franco-allemande
La lumière du Droit rayonne au bout du chemin





Directeur de la publication : Joël-François Dumont
Comité de rédaction : Jacques de Lestapis, Hugues Dumont, François de Vries (Bruxelles), Hans-Ulrich Helfer (Suisse), Michael Hellerforth (Allemagne).
Comité militaire : VAE Guy Labouérie (†), GAA François Mermet (2S), CF Patrice Théry (Asie).

Contact